"You can find an article on the internet about how modern Native Americans still revere their root culture. Provide a link to the article and post a reflection about it."
http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/2010/03/14/20100314native-american-teachers.html
This article is about a young woman who became a teacher to Native American children on the Navajo reservation in Arizona, near Tucson. Her name is Shannon Begaye and she is a member of the Navajo tribe. Shannon had never planned on becoming a teacher, because she wanted to be a lawyer. She tried to move away and start life in other places, but she found it very hard because of the culture and the way she was raised. When she lived in Hawaii she loved the people but would always have to remember her religion in everything she did. Shannon says her father upholds all the old Navajo traditions. For example, she was raised that she could not enter the water of the ocean without prayer first,m because the ocean is a powerful life force. I personally think that this would b redundant after awhile, because living in Hawaii tends to deal with its water a lot. The Navajo also believe that shellfish is bad for the spirit, so she wasn't able to eat shellfish. I wouldn't mind this, because i don't eat shellfish or any other fish anyway.
When she moved back to the reservation, her mother had known she would come back. In my opinion, Shannon was raised almost if to never leave. I know that all people have a right to live how they want to and where they want to, but i think she was raised in a way that made it too hard for her to move away.
On the reverse of that point, the culture of the Navajo is slowly dying. So when Shannon went back to the reservation, she was doing her tribe somewhat of a favor. They are in such need of teachers to teach the native children, because any non-native does not understand the children and the ways they live. Its so much harder to teach a person a culture and make them understand it, than to just find a teacher who was raised with it. It talks about this in the article, and how outside teachers tend to block themselves off from the culture and the tribe. This of course gets them no where with the kids.
This article made me think alittle about how these people live and how they raise their children. So here is my question, is it better to raise your child to stay in the tribe and live in a way that is hard to part with, or fall away from your culture to make life easier to mesh with the outside world?
You have written a good reflection on the article, and the question you post is one that has been asked since the culture conflict began.
ReplyDeleteYour question is really deep. From what I've learned, I have always wondered what the pros and cons are to keeping your child in the tribe and staying apart from the outside world to joining in with the outside world. It'd be interesting to find out what they think about it themselves.
ReplyDelete